Monday 27 February 2017

Slavoj Žižek: What our fear of refugees says about Europe

The true question is not “are immigrants a real threat to Europe?”, but “what does this obsession with the immigrant threat tell us about the weakness of Europe?”

Jacques Lacan claimed that, even if a jealous husband's claim about his wife – that she sleeps around with other men – is true, his jealousy is still pathological. Why? The true question is “not is his jealousy well-grounded?”, but “why does he need jealousy to maintain his self-identity?”. Along the same lines, one could say that even if most of the Nazi claims about the Jews were true – they exploit Germans; they seduce German girls – which they were not, of course, their anti-Semitism would still be (and was) pathological, since it represses the true reason why the Nazis needed anti-Semitism in order to sustain their ideological position.

And is it not exactly the same with the growing fear of refugees and immigrants? To extrapolate to the extreme: even if most of our prejudices about them were proven to be true – they are hidden fundamentalist terrorists; they rape and steal – the paranoid talk about the immigrant threat is still an ideological pathology. It tells more about us, Europeans, than about immigrants. The true question is not “are immigrants a real threat to Europe?”, but “what does this obsession with the immigrant threat tell us about the weakness of Europe?”

There are two dimensions here which should be kept apart. One is the atmosphere of fear, of the struggle against the Islamization of Europe, which has its own obvious absurdities. Refugees who flee terror are equated with the terrorists they are escaping from. The obvious fact that there are terrorists, rapists, criminals etc, among the refugees, while the large majority are desperate people looking for a better life – in the same way that, among the refugees from the German Democratic Republic, there were also hidden Stasi agents – is given a paranoid twist. In this version, immigrants appear (or pretend) to be desperate refugees, while in reality they are the speahead of a new Islamic invasion of Europe. Above all, as is usually the case, the cause of problems which are immanent to today's global capitalism are projected onto an external intruder. A suspicious gaze always finds what it is looking for: “proof” is everywhere, even if half of it is soon proven to be fake.

Eat less and READ MORE!

4 comments:

  1. It says, "Europe's economy is failing, and these are just more competitors for YOUR job!"

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jobs that so many Europeans don't want to anymore, like scrubbing toilets for t'minimum wage? ;-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, that's what regular-order (not refugee) immigration is for. I'm talking about the shop-boys, bartenders, miners, factory/mill workers and every "average guy" local who's job gets replaced by a machine, gets "off-shored," or is surrendered to some corporate franchise ala WalMart/McDonald's or CVS Pharmacy

      Delete
    2. Bill Gates had a brain fart the other day and said that "robots" ought to pay taxes. Personally, I prefer the idea of not allowing to corporations to get big enough to be able to "purchase" robots in the first place.

      Delete